If you've ever reached for a box of Smucker's Uncrustables, then you'll feel right at home with Trader Joe's latest freezer find. Their Crustless Peanut Butter and Strawberry Jam Sandwiches are basically TJ's take on the school-lunch classic: soft bread, creamy peanut butter, and sweet strawberry jam, all sealed up into a tidy little pocket.
Jump to:
Review
Found in the frozen aisle, each sandwich comes individually wrapped and ready to thaw. Just pull one out in the morning, toss it in a lunchbox, and by the time lunchtime rolls around, it's soft and ready to eat. The bread is fluffy, the crust is trimmed, and the filling ratio leans more peanut butter-heavy than jam.
Taste-wise, I thought these were just as good as Uncrustables. The peanut butter is creamy and has that familiar roasted nuttiness, while the strawberry jam adds sweetness without being cloying. However, the ratio might divide PB&J lovers - if you like your sandwich jammy, you may feel like the jam got benched here. If you're a peanut butter fan, you'll be thrilled.
Where I think Trader Joe's missed an opportunity is in creativity. They basically recreated Uncrustables without putting their own spin on it. A sunbutter version, an almond butter version, or even rotating seasonal jams (hello, cherry or apricot!) would have made this a standout.
On a personal note, my son is starting kindergarten this September, and we were already told his classroom will be peanut-free. That rules these sandwiches out as a school lunch option, which I know many parents will relate to. With food allergies on the rise, I'd love to see Trader Joe's create a school-friendly version of this product.
That being said, I did enjoy them. They're convenient, tasty, and nostalgic - just maybe better suited for after-school snacks, quick breakfasts, or adults who want to relive their PB&J glory days.
On a side note, these are about $1 each. If you go through a lot of these or have multiple people in a household who enjoy these, then you may be better off just buying the sandwich cutter and using your own ingredients, which is more economical in the long run and allows for more varieties.
Creative Uses
- Breakfast Hack: Toast and drizzle with honey or maple syrup.
- Dessert PB&J: Spread with Nutella or dip into melted chocolate.
- PB&J French Toast: Dip in egg mixture and cook for a decadent brunch treat.
- Snack Attack: Cut into quarters and serve with apple slices and cheese cubes for a fun snack plate.
Safe School Lunch Ideas
If you are in the same situation as me, the following items from Trader Joe's might be safer options:
- Trader Joe's Mac and Cheese (Boxed) or Mac and Cheese Bites- Obviously heat ahead and pack into a thermos for a warm comforting lunch
- Trader Joe's Chicken Nuggets- They are sold in the refrigerated aisle and come in regular or spicy. We are all waiting to see if the drumellas make a return to store shelves.
- Trader Joe's Spaghetti and Meat Sauce- Portion and pack into a thermos for a hearty and beefy lunch option.
FAQs
Below is a list of frequently asked questions Trader Joe's Crustless Peanut Butter and Strawberry Jam Sandwiches
They are pretty much the same except Trader Joe's only sells the strawberry flavor.
Yes, you can! A quick toast can crisp up the outside and make the middle a little more gooey.
Depending on your school's rules on peanuts, they may or may not be a safe bet.
Final Thoughts
Overall, Trader Joe's Crustless Peanut Butter and Strawberry Jam Sandwiches are tasty, nostalgic, and convenient, but they don't feel particularly original. They're a solid option for at-home snacks or quick meals, but I'd love to see Trader Joe's expand into allergy-friendly or more creative variations. Still, if you're a fan of PB-heavy sandwiches, you'll keep a box in your freezer. Otherwise, look into getting a sandwich cutter if you go through a lot of these for limitless possibilities.
Do you love these reviews?
Don't forget to share your thoughts by going to the "user review" at the bottom of the box (click on the number of stars you believe this product deserves) and leave a comment below.
Are you a fan of Substack? You can follow me here.
You can also FOLLOW ME on the following platforms by clicking the icons below:
Trader Joe's Crustless Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jam Sandwiches
Product Name: Trader Joe's Crustless Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jam Sandwiches
Product Description: Trader Joe's Crustless Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jam is essential just a dupe of the popular UnCrustables.
Price: $3.79
Currency: USD
Availability: InStoreOnly
Summary
Let's call it what it is: Trader Joe's Crustless Sandwiches are basically Uncrustables with a different name and a more limited flavor variety.
-
Taste
-
Value
-
Worthy of Repurchasing
Pros
-
Convenient – Frozen and individually wrapped, ready to toss into a bag.
-
Good flavor – Creamy peanut butter + sweet strawberry jam.
-
Soft, crustless bread – Just like the original Uncrustables.
Cons
-
Peanut butter heavy – Jam lovers may be disappointed.
-
Not allergy-friendly – Can’t be packed in peanut-free schools.
-
Lacks creativity – Feels more like a copy than a Trader Joe’s original.
I'd love to hear what you think! Leave a comment below and share your thoughts.