blog - BecomeBetty.com

Trader Joe's Al Pastor Diced Pork Shoulder

Trader Joe's refrigerated meat section has been doing a lot of the heavy lifting for people who want dinner without actually wanting to make dinner.

And honestly, I respect that.

Trader Joe's Al Pastor Diced Pork Shoulder joins the lineup at $6.49 per pound, with most packages hovering around 1.5 pounds. It's already seasoned, already cut, and basically begging you to grab some tortillas and call it Taco Tuesday.

That's exactly what I did.

Unfortunately, while this made an incredibly easy taco dinner, the flavor didn't quite deliver what I wanted from something labeled al pastor.

It wasn't bad.

It just wasn't particularly memorable either.

Trader Joe's Al Pastor Diced Pork Shoulder unopened on a pink surface.

[feast_advanced_jump_to]

Review

The first surprise happened when I opened the package.

Trader Joe's calls this Diced Pork Shoulder, but "diced" isn't quite how I would describe what came out of my package.

This pork is chopped extremely fine. We're approaching minced territory.

Looking through the package, I expected more distinct pieces of pork shoulder. Once it hit the pan and I started breaking everything apart, the texture became much more apparent.

Fortunately, I didn't dislike the texture.

It actually works pretty well inside a taco. The small pieces mean you get pork in every bite, and there's no struggling with a giant chunk of meat while half the contents of your taco fall onto your plate.

We've all been there. But if you're expecting larger, meatier pieces of pork based on the appearance through the packaging, you might be surprised.

When I think of a really good al pastor, I want layers of flavor.

There should be savory seasoning, some sweetness, and a smoky quality that makes you immediately want another taco.

Trader Joe's gets part of the way there.

The savory flavor is definitely present.

There's also a little sweetness in the background.

But the smoky element? That's where I felt like somebody forgot to finish the sentence.

I kept waiting for that deeper smoky flavor to show up and bring everything together.

It never really did. The result isn't unpleasant. It's seasoned pork, and seasoned pork inside a warm tortilla is rarely going to ruin my evening.

But this tastes more like decent pre-seasoned taco meat than something that made me think, "Now THAT'S al pastor."

And when the name on the package creates a certain flavor expectation, decent taco meat isn't quite enough.

Can You Air Fry Trader Joe's Al Pastor Diced Pork Shoulder?

Personally, I wouldn't make the air fryer my first choice.

Normally, I'm all for throwing Trader Joe's pre-marinated meats into the air fryer and letting it handle dinner.

But because this pork is chopped so finely, I think a skillet gives you much better control.

In the pan, I needed to stir and move the pork around frequently so all those tiny pieces cooked evenly.

With larger pieces of meat, an air fryer makes perfect sense because hot air can circulate around them.

With something approaching a minced texture, I'd be concerned about getting everything spread appropriately and cooked evenly without creating a mess.

Could it potentially work with the right air fryer setup? Probably.

Would I choose that over a skillet?

Nope.

This is one where I'd grab the frying pan.

Nutritional facts, ingredients in Trader Joe's Al Pastor Diced Pork Shoulder.

Serving Suggestions

Tacos are the obvious answer, but you've got options.

Tacos: Warm some corn or flour tortillas and add the pork with diced onion, cilantro, salsa, and a squeeze of lime.
Add pineapple: Since I wanted more sweet and smoky contrast, some caramelized or grilled pineapple could help bring another dimension to the pork.
Burrito bowls: Serve over rice with beans, corn, salsa, avocado, and your favorite toppings.
Quesadillas: Add the cooked pork to a cheese quesadilla for an extremely easy dinner.
Nachos: Scatter the cooked pork over tortilla chips with cheese, jalapeños, salsa, and sour cream.
Breakfast: Leftovers could easily find their way into scrambled eggs or breakfast tacos the next morning.

Because the seasoning isn't especially aggressive, this pork is actually pretty versatile. That's simultaneously one of its strengths and one of its weaknesses.

Fully cooked Trader Joe's Al Pastor Diced Pork Shoulder in a pan.

FAQs about Trader Joe's Al Pastor Diced Pork Shoulder

The following are commonly asked questions about this product:

How much is Trader Joe's Al Pastor Diced Pork Shoulder?

It's $6.49 per pound. Most packages I saw were around 1.5 pounds, so expect to pay roughly $9 to $10 per package, depending on weight.

Would I buy Trader Joe's Al Pastor Diced Pork Shoulder again?

Probably not regularly. I didn't dislike it. It made an incredibly easy taco dinner, and the pork itself was perfectly fine. But when I buy something labeled al pastor, I want a combination of sweet, savory, and smoky flavors that makes me excited about the next bite. This didn't quite get there.

Is the pork actually diced?

Technically, yes, but the pieces in my package were extremely small. I would describe the texture as very finely chopped and approaching minced.

Two tacos with Trader Joe's Al Pasto, Pickled Red Onions, and Queso Fresco. — Trader Joe's al pastor tacos with pickled red onions and queso fresco.

Final Thoughts

Trader Joe's Al Pastor Diced Pork Shoulder falls squarely into the category of not bad, not great. The convenience is absolutely there.

For around $10 per package, you can get a taco dinner on the table with almost no preparation. The finely chopped texture works surprisingly well inside tortillas, and the pork cooks quickly in a skillet.

But convenience can't completely make up for flavor. The savory notes were there. There was a little sweetness. But I kept waiting for the smoky depth that would bring everything together and make this taste like something more than seasoned pork.

It never arrived. If your priority is getting taco night onto the table as quickly as possible, I can see the appeal.

If you're looking for an al pastor that knocks it out of the park?

This isn't it. Not bad enough to leave behind with regret. Not good enough to become a regular purchase. For me, this one's sitting firmly in the middle of the Trader Joe's road.

Do you love these reviews?

Don't forget to share your thoughts by going to the "user review" at the bottom of the box (click on the number of stars you believe this product deserves) and leave a comment below.

Are you a fan of SubStack? You can follow me here.

You can also FOLLOW ME on the following platforms by clicking the icons below:

Trader Joe's Protein Pancakes Review: Flippin' Good, Flippin' Pricey

Apparently we've reached the point where even making pancakes is too much work.

And honestly?

Some mornings, Trader Joe's knows me better than I'd like to admit.

Trader Joe's Protein Pancakes are sold in the refrigerated aisle for $3.79. You get four fully prepared pancakes with 20 grams of protein per package, that just need to be heated and served.

They're thin, surprisingly filling, and taste remarkably similar to regular pancakes despite having a pretty different ingredient profile.

The problem?

Four pancakes.

$3.79.

Convenience has entered the chat, and apparently, it wants to be paid.

Trader Joe's Protein Pancakes on a pink surface.

[feast_advanced_jump_to]

Review

Let's start with the good news.

These are good pancakes.

If someone put a plate of these in front of me without telling me they were protein pancakes, I'm not sure I would immediately know there was anything particularly different about them.

And I mean that as a compliment.

Protein-enhanced versions of familiar foods can sometimes announce themselves immediately with an unusual flavor or texture.

These really don't.

They taste like pancakes.

They're thinner than the big, fluffy pancakes you might get at a diner, but they're still satisfying and surprisingly filling.

I heated mine in the microwave, which left them a little soft, but they were still enjoyable.

Would another cooking method give you a slightly better exterior texture?

Probably.

But if I'm buying premade pancakes from the refrigerated aisle, I'm probably not doing it because I suddenly feel inspired to break out a griddle.

Convenience is the entire point.

What Do Trader Joe's Protein Pancakes Taste Like?

Like pancakes.

I realize that isn't the most dramatic tasting note I've ever written, but it's probably the most useful one.

Despite the different ingredients and added emphasis on protein, there isn't some strange protein-product flavor dominating the experience.

They're mild, slightly sweet, and neutral enough to work with whatever toppings you normally put on pancakes. They're gluten-free and the protein is coming from the cottage cheese.

The pancakes themselves aren't trying to be the star of breakfast. They're basically giving you a blank canvas with some extra staying power.

Let's Talk About the Texture

These aren't particularly thick pancakes.

They're relatively thin, especially compared with a big stack of fluffy homemade or restaurant pancakes.

That doesn't mean they're flimsy or unsatisfying, though.

In fact, I found them surprisingly filling.

After heating them in the microwave, the texture became fairly soft. That's not necessarily a dealbreaker for pancakes, but if you prefer some browning or slightly firmer edges, the microwave probably isn't going to deliver that.

For speed? Perfectly fine.

I had hot pancakes in basically no time without dirtying a mixing bowl, whisk, measuring cup, or frying pan.

There is something to be said for that.

The Biggest Problem Is the Price

Here's where I have a harder time getting excited.

Trader Joe's Protein Pancakes are $3.79 for four pancakes.

That's almost 95 cents per pancake.

And these aren't enormous pancakes.

From a pure value standpoint, that's expensive for what you're getting.

You're not really paying for flour and pancake ingredients here.

You're paying Trader Joe's to make the pancakes for you, package them, and put them in the refrigerated aisle so that your morning effort consists largely of opening the package.

There are absolutely mornings when that has value.

But there are also mornings when I'd look at $3.79 for four relatively thin pancakes and think, "I own a mixing bowl."

Are Trader Joe's Protein Pancakes Worth $3.79?

This depends almost entirely on why you're buying them.

If your primary concern is value, probably not.

Four thin pancakes for $3.79 is hard to call a bargain.

If your priority is convenience and protein, the argument gets stronger.

They're already made.

They're refrigerated rather than frozen.

They heat quickly.

They're filling.

And most importantly, they don't taste like you're eating a compromise just because they're marketed around protein.

That's probably their biggest success.

Trader Joe's managed to make a protein-focused pancake that still tastes like a normal pancake.

I just wish normal pancakes hadn't suddenly developed such expensive taste.

Nutritional facts and ingredients in Trader Joe's Protein Pancakes.

Serving Suggestions

Because the pancakes themselves are relatively neutral, you've got plenty of options.

Maple syrup: Keep it classic. Warm pancakes plus maple syrup requires very little explanation.
Fresh berries: Strawberries, blueberries, or raspberries add freshness without making breakfast feel too heavy.
Banana: Slice a banana over the top for an easy, filling breakfast.
Granola Butter: Trader Joe's Granola Butter would be a particularly fun pairing because its oat, maple, brown sugar, and vanilla flavors naturally work with pancakes.
Peanut or almond butter: An easy way to make an already filling breakfast even more substantial.
Greek yogurt and fruit: If that's your thing, add a spoonful with berries for a protein-focused breakfast.
Cinnamon and apples: Warm sliced apples with cinnamon would turn these into something that feels much more like a weekend breakfast.
Breakfast sandwich: Use two pancakes as the "bread" around egg and cheese for a sweet and savory breakfast sandwich.
Roll them up: Because they're thin, try spreading them with your favorite nut, seed, or granola butter and rolling them around sliced banana.

Two of Trader Joe's Protein Pancakes on a plate with butter on the top next to the original packaging.

FAQs about Trader Joe's Protein Pancakes

The following are commonly asked questions about this product:

How much protein is in Trader Joe's Protein Pancakes?

The package contains 20 grams of protein across four pancakes, which works out to about 5 grams per pancake.

What do Trader Joe's Protein Pancakes taste like?

Surprisingly similar to regular pancakes. Despite the different ingredient profile and added protein, I didn't find the flavor dramatically different from an ordinary pancake.

How do they compare with Trader Joe's Protein Pancake Mix?

The obvious advantage is convenience. With the refrigerated pancakes, Trader Joe's has already done the cooking for you. If you're happy making pancakes from the Protein Pancake Mix, that's likely the better route when convenience isn't your priority.

Final Thoughts

Trader Joe's Protein Pancakes are a good product trapped inside a questionable value proposition.

The pancakes taste good.

They're thin but filling.

They don't have an obvious protein-product taste.

And they can go from refrigerator to breakfast plate in practically no time.

All wins.

Then you remember you're paying $3.79 for four pancakes.

That's where I hesitate.

If getting more protein into your breakfast is a priority and Trader Joe's Protein Pancake Mix isn't doing it for you, these are a convenient alternative.

If you need Trader Joe's to make the pancakes for you?

They've got you.

Just know they're charging you for the favor.

For me, these fall into the category of good product, premium convenience.

I'd happily eat them again.

I'm just not sure I'd happily pay almost a dollar per pancake every time.

Do you love these reviews?

Don't forget to share your thoughts by going to the "user review" at the bottom of the box (click on the number of stars you believe this product deserves) and leave a comment below.

Are you a fan of SubStack? You can follow me here.

You can also FOLLOW ME on the following platforms by clicking the icons below:

Trader Joe's Passion Fruit Orange Guava Juice Review: POG Juice Without the Mouse

Passion fruit. Orange. Guava. POG.

If you've spent enough time at Disney, that combination might already sound very familiar. Trader Joe's Passion Fruit Orange Guava Juice is sold in four-packs of 8.45-ounce cans for $4.49. For a while, this seemed like one of those Trader Joe's products that appeared briefly and then vanished before you could decide whether you liked it.

Thankfully, it seems to be making another appearance on shelves, and I'm happy about that because this has become a regular purchase in my household. It's sweet, tropical, a little tart, and while it's perfectly good straight from the can, this juice is practically begging you to start mixing things into it.

An unopened box of Trader Joe's Passion Fruit Orange Guava Juice.

[feast_advanced_jump_to]

Review

Let's address the obvious first. Yes, this is sweet. If you're expecting something light, delicate, or barely sweet tasting, this isn't that. But what I appreciate is what's actually creating the juice blend. You've got passion fruit, orange, and guava. That's it for the juices. There's no apple juice quietly doing most of the work and no water cutting down those tropical flavors.

When Trader Joe's says Passion Fruit Orange Guava Juice, those are the flavors you're getting, and they work remarkably well together. The orange and guava bring plenty of sweetness and tropical fruit flavor, while passion fruit provides some much-needed tartness. Without that passion fruit, I think this could easily cross the line into too sweet. Instead, you get some balance.

It's still firmly on the sweet side, but there's enough acidity to keep me coming back for another sip. It's a tropical vacation in a can. That's probably the easiest description.

The orange is familiar and juicy, guava adds a sweeter and more tropical quality, and then passion fruit comes through with that distinctive tartness that keeps everything interesting. None of the three completely disappears. More importantly, the drink doesn't taste like generic "tropical fruit punch." You can actually tell there are specific fruit flavors working together.

The overall flavor is bold, fruity, and sweet with enough tanginess to provide some contrast. And you absolutely want this cold. Room-temperature tropical juice isn't the vibe. Get those cans into the refrigerator.

This isn't a subtle juice. Guava and orange bring plenty of sweetness, and there's no water diluting the blend. Fortunately, passion fruit is doing important work here. Its tartness provides contrast and keeps the juice from becoming completely one-dimensional.

That's why the combination works for me. You get sweet, tropical, and tart in the same sip. If you don't like sweet fruit juice, this probably isn't going to convert you. But if you enjoy tropical flavors, there's a lot to like.

You get four 8.45-ounce cans for $4.49, which works out to a little over $1.12 per can. I actually like the individual format here.

A large bottle of juice requires you to open the whole thing and then remember that it's sitting in the refrigerator. With these, you can chill a can, crack it open, and you're done. The size also works particularly well if you're using the juice as a cocktail or mocktail mixer.

And that's where this product gets much more interesting.

Nutritional fact and ingredients in Trader Joe's Passion Fruit Orange Guava Juice.

How to Enjoy

Trader Joe's Passion Fruit Orange Guava Juice is perfectly enjoyable straight from the can. But every time I drink it, part of my brain starts thinking: What can we add to this?

For the 21+ crowd, this is basically a tropical cocktail starter kit. The sweet-tart fruit combination can pair with several different spirits, and the juice already provides enough flavor that you don't need to build a complicated cocktail around it.

POG Mimosa

This might be the most obvious use. Replace some or all of the traditional orange juice in a mimosa with Trader Joe's POG Juice. POG juice plus sparkling wine. Done.

You get something more tropical and interesting than the standard orange juice version without creating extra work. Brunch just got an upgrade.

POG Rum Punch

Rum and tropical fruit are already good friends. Combine the POG Juice with rum, plenty of ice, and a squeeze of lime. If you want some fizz, add sparkling water.

POG Tequila Cocktail

Tequila, POG Juice, and fresh lime would make an extremely easy tropical drink. Salt or Tajín on the rim could give you a savory contrast against the sweet juice.

POG Vodka Spritz

Combine POG Juice, vodka, sparkling water, and lime. Easy, cold, refreshing, and no bartender certification required.

Don't Forget the Mocktails

You don't need alcohol to turn this into something more interesting. In fact, because the juice already has such a strong flavor profile, mocktails are incredibly easy.

POG Fizz: Pour the juice over ice and top with sparkling water and fresh lime. The sparkling water also helps tone down the sweetness if you find the juice a little intense on its own.
Tropical Ginger POG: Combine POG Juice with ginger beer and fresh lime. The ginger adds spice and keeps the drink from becoming too sweet.
POG Sunrise: Pour the juice over ice and add a small amount of grenadine for a layered tropical drink. Finish with an orange slice if you're feeling fancy.
Coconut POG Cooler: Combine the juice with coconut water and plenty of ice. This lightens the sweetness while keeping everything firmly in tropical territory.
Frozen POG Slush: Freeze some of the juice into ice cubes and blend them with additional chilled juice. Suddenly we're one tiny umbrella away from vacation.

Don't limit this to drinking straight from the can. Freeze it into popsicles, use it to make tropical ice cubes, add a splash to smoothies with mango, pineapple, or banana, or combine several cans with sparkling water and fresh citrus for an easy party punch.

You could also freeze it in a shallow pan and scrape it with a fork for an easy tropical granita. There's a surprising amount you can do with four little cans.

FAQs about Trader Joe's Passion Fruit Orange Guava Juice

The following are commonly asked questions about this product:

How much is Trader Joe's Passion Fruit Orange Guava Juice?

It's $4.49 for four 8.45-ounce cans.

Should Trader Joe's POG Juice be served cold?

Absolutely. I think it's substantially better well chilled.

Is Trader Joe's Passion Fruit Orange Guava Juice sweet?

Yes. This definitely leans sweet, although the tartness from the passion fruit helps balance it.

An open box of Trader Joe's Passion Fruit Orange Guava Juice showing the can.

Final Thoughts

Trader Joe's Passion Fruit Orange Guava Juice is one of those products I'm genuinely happy to see back on shelves. It's sweet, tart, and unapologetically tropical. Most importantly, it actually tastes like the three fruits advertised on the can.

Passion fruit keeps the sweeter orange and guava flavors from becoming overwhelming, while the individual cans make this easy to keep chilled and ready to go. Drink it straight from the refrigerator and it's good. Turn it into a mimosa? Even better.

Start experimenting with sparkling water, ginger beer, lime, or frozen drinks and suddenly those four little cans have a lot more potential than you might expect.

At $4.49, this has become a regular purchase in my household. Sometimes I drink it straight. Sometimes it becomes a mocktail. And sometimes brunch happens.

I'm not judging any of those choices.

Do you love these reviews?

Don't forget to share your thoughts by going to the "user review" at the bottom of the box (click on the number of stars you believe this product deserves) and leave a comment below.

Are you a fan of SubStack? You can follow me here.

You can also FOLLOW ME on the following platforms by clicking the icons below:

Trader Joe's Basque Style Cheesecakes Review: Put This on the Permanent Basque-et

Every once in a while, Trader Joe's releases something that makes me question one of their favorite business decisions:

Why is this a limited run?

Trader Joe's Basque Style Cheesecakes are sold frozen for $4.99. Inside the box are two individually portioned cheesecakes, each with a dramatically browned top that might make you wonder whether someone at the factory forgot to set a timer.

They didn't. That's the point. These were my first experience with Basque-style cheesecake, and after one bite I understood the appeal.

These are absolutely delicious.

Trader Joe's, we're going to need to discuss that "limited run" situation.

An unopened box of Trader Joe's Basque Style Cheesecakes.

[feast_advanced_jump_to]

Review

Cheesecake comes in a lot of different styles.

You've got classic New York cheesecake, flavored cheesecakes, no-bake cheesecake, Japanese cheesecake, and apparently an entire cheesecake universe I haven't completely worked my way through yet.

Basque cheesecake was one of the styles I hadn't tried.

So when I opened the package and saw just how browned these were on top, I wasn't entirely sure what to expect.

But then I took a bite.

Oh. These are good. Really good.

There's a beautiful balance between sweetness and that slightly tangy, cheesy flavor you actually want from cheesecake.

They're rich without becoming obnoxiously sweet, and the individual size is just about perfect.

I went into this expecting to review another frozen Trader Joe's dessert.

I finished it wondering why Trader Joe's isn't selling these all year.

What Is Basque Cheesecake?

If you've never had Basque cheesecake before, the appearance might throw you off.

That dramatically dark top is intentional.

Basque-style cheesecake originated in San Sebastián, Spain, at a restaurant called La Viña. Unlike the classic American cheesecake many of us are familiar with, traditional Basque cheesecake doesn't have a graham cracker crust.

It's baked at a much higher temperature, which creates its signature deeply browned, caramelized exterior while the inside remains especially soft and creamy.

So that dark top?

That's not the cheesecake equivalent of forgetting something in the oven.

That's the assignment.

And it gives Basque cheesecake a very different personality from the pale, perfectly smooth cheesecakes you might be used to seeing.

What Do Trader Joe's Basque Style Cheesecakes Taste Like?

The first thing I appreciated was the balance.

These aren't sugar bombs.

You get sweetness, obviously, but there's enough tangy cream cheese flavor coming through to remind you that you're actually eating cheesecake.

That's important.

Sometimes cheesecake becomes so loaded with sugar, toppings, sauces, crusts, and other flavors that the actual cheese component gets lost.

Not here. This tastes like cheesecake: sweet, creamy, slightly tangy, and rich.

And then you get that deeply browned exterior adding another dimension to the whole thing.

It's relatively simple, and that's exactly why it works.

About That Browned Top

If you're unfamiliar with Basque cheesecake, you might take one look at these and think:

Did Trader Joe's burn my dessert?

Nope. Mine weren't quite as dark as the picture would have you believe.

In fact, the browned top is arguably the most important visual characteristic of Basque-style cheesecake.

The high-heat baking process creates that dramatically caramelized exterior, which provides contrast with the creamy filling underneath.

And Trader Joe's definitely committed to the look.

Don't judge them by appearance alone.

That dark top is hiding a very good cheesecake underneath.

The interior is creamy and rich without being excessively dense.

That's another place where these distinguish themselves from a classic New York-style cheesecake.

A traditional New York cheesecake can be quite dense, firm, and substantial.

This feels softer and creamier.

The contrast between that deeply browned exterior and the creamy interior makes each bite more interesting than the relatively simple ingredient concept might suggest.

And because each cheesecake is individually portioned, you get plenty of that exterior in relation to the creamy center.

I'm not complaining.

Trader Joe's didn't make the mistake of turning cheesecake into pure sugar.

There's enough sweetness to make this clearly dessert, but there's also enough cream cheese flavor to provide some tanginess and balance.

That's exactly what I want.

Sweet cheesecake is good.

Cheesecake that still tastes like cheese is better.

And these manage that balance beautifully. My only complaint is that this is right now a limited-run item.

Nutritional facts and ingredients in Trader Joe's Basque Style Cheesecakes.

Serving Suggestions

Personally? I'd start by doing absolutely nothing. These don't need help.

But if you want to dress them up, there are some easy options.

Fresh berries: Strawberries, raspberries, or blueberries would add some acidity and freshness against the rich cheesecake.
Berry sauce: A simple raspberry or strawberry sauce would work beautifully without overpowering the cheesecake.
Espresso: Rich cheesecake and strong coffee are natural partners.
Fresh whipped cream: Keep it lightly sweetened so the cheesecake remains the star.
A little sea salt: If you enjoy sweet and salty desserts, the tiniest sprinkle could emphasize the caramelized flavor of the browned exterior.
Fresh fruit: Sliced peaches or other slightly tart fruit could work nicely when in season.

But again, none of this is necessary. Take it out of the package. Put it on a plate. Grab a fork. Done.

FAQs about Trader Joe's Basque Style Cheesecakes

The following are commonly asked questions about this product:

Where can you find Trader Joe's Basque Style Cheesecakes?

They're sold in the freezer section.

Does Basque cheesecake have a crust?

Traditional Basque-style cheesecake is crustless, which makes it different from the graham cracker crust many people associate with American cheesecake.

Is Basque cheesecake supposed to taste burnt?

Trader Joe's Basque cheesecakes are a little dark on top, but don't push into the burnt arena.

An open package of Trader Joe's Basque Style Cheesecakes showing 1 of the desserts.

Final Thoughts

Sometimes Trader Joe's releases a limited-run product and I understand why. It's interesting. You try it once. You move on.

Trader Joe's Basque Style Cheesecakes are not one of those products.

Make these permanent. Please.

The deeply browned appearance initially caught me off guard because I'd never had Basque cheesecake before.

The flavor won me over immediately.

They're creamy without being excessively dense, sweet without being cloying, and tangy enough that the cream cheese flavor isn't lost.

Even better, the individual portions are just right.

At $4.99 for two, I think these are an easy recommendation for cheesecake fans.

My only real regret? There were only two in the box.

Trader Joe's, you've made your point.

Now put them in the freezer aisle permanently.

Do you love these reviews?

Don't forget to share your thoughts by going to the "user review" at the bottom of the box (click on the number of stars you believe this product deserves) and leave a comment below.

Are you a fan of SubStack? You can follow me here.

You can also FOLLOW ME on the following platforms by clicking the icons below:

Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan Review: Flan-tastic in Theory

Every fall, Trader Joe's reaches a point where seemingly nothing is safe from pumpkin spice.

Cookies? Obviously. Coffee? Expected. Pasta? We've been down that road.

Flan? Sure. Why not.

Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan is a seasonal spin on the year-round Caramel Flan you'll find in the refrigerated aisle. A package is $3.49 and contains two individually portioned flans.

Since Trader Joe's regular Caramel Flan is actually pretty good for something premade and sitting in the refrigerator case, I went into this with reasonably high expectations.

Pumpkin plus creamy custard plus caramel sounded like it should work.

What I wasn't prepared for was just how much pumpkin spice was about to enter the conversation.

And then refuse to stop talking.

An unopened package of Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan.

[feast_advanced_jump_to]

Review

I underestimated this dessert.

I looked at Pumpkin Flan and expected the familiar creamy custard and caramel flavors of the regular version, only with some pumpkin and warm fall spices added.

Instead, pumpkin spice basically kicked down the door.

The spice profile here is assertive. Actually, I'd go a little further.

It's overwhelming.

Rather than tasting creamy custard, pumpkin, caramel, and spice as separate but complementary flavors, the spice seems to dominate nearly everything else.

That's a problem because flan is normally a pretty delicate dessert.

Custard isn't exactly known for screaming for attention.

Caramel can bring some deeper sweetness and slight bitterness.

Pumpkin could have added earthy sweetness and richness.

Those elements had the potential to work beautifully together.

Instead, pumpkin spice grabbed the microphone and didn't give it back.

The first thing I noticed wasn't caramel. It wasn't creamy custard. It wasn't even pumpkin. It was pumpkin spice. And plenty of it.

The warm spice profile is substantially stronger than I expected and overwhelms some of the subtler flavors that should be part of the dessert.

If you're someone who waits all year for pumpkin spice season and thinks there's no such thing as too much cinnamon-and-spice flavor, you might enjoy this much more than I did.

Personally, I wanted balance.

A good seasonal variation should still remind me of the original product while bringing something new.

Here, I found myself searching for the caramel and custard underneath all that spice.

One of the things I enjoy about flan is the contrast between creamy custard and caramel.

Unfortunately, the caramel doesn't get much opportunity to shine here.

The pumpkin spice profile is so assertive that the caramel flavor gets pushed into the background.

And I don't think the texture of the caramel layer helped.

I found the top slightly more rubbery than I expected.

The regular Caramel Flan sets a reasonably good baseline for what Trader Joe's can do with a premade refrigerated flan, so I was disappointed that the seasonal version didn't seem to hit the same mark.

The caramel should have been one of the flavors balancing the pumpkin and spices.

Instead, it feels more like an afterthought.

What About the Pumpkin?

Here's where things get interesting.

Based purely on the name, I expected pumpkin to be a major part of the experience.

But what stood out to me much more clearly was pumpkin spice flavor.

The natural flavors in the ingredient list certainly seem to be doing some heavy lifting in creating that seasonal spice profile.

And that's ultimately my biggest issue.

I wanted pumpkin flan.

What I tasted felt closer to pumpkin spice flan.

Those are not necessarily the same thing.

Pumpkin itself can be mild, earthy, slightly sweet, and creamy.

Pumpkin spice can be loud.

This particular dessert chose loud.

A close up of the bite of Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan.

How Does It Compare to Trader Joe's Caramel Flan?

I'd choose the regular Caramel Flan.

Pretty easily.

Trader Joe's year-round version isn't going to replace a beautifully made restaurant flan, but for a premade refrigerated dessert, it's pretty solid.

And that's exactly why I had higher hopes for the Pumpkin Flan.

The regular version allows the creamy custard and caramel to do their thing.

The Pumpkin Flan adds such an assertive spice profile that those flavors become harder to appreciate.

Sometimes adding more flavor doesn't actually make something more flavorful.

It just makes it louder.

That's what happened here.

At $3.49 for two individually portioned desserts, I don't think the price is unreasonable.

You're getting two convenient, ready-to-eat seasonal desserts for less than $2 each.

My issue isn't the value.

It's what else Trader Joe's sells during pumpkin season.

There are so many pumpkin products competing for your attention, money, and available stomach space that merely being okay isn't enough.

And that's where Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan lands for me.

Okay.

Not terrible.

Not something I'd warn everyone to avoid.

But definitely not something I'm planning to stock up on before pumpkin season ends.

There are simply better pumpkin treats at Trader Joe's.

Nutritional facts, ingredients in Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan.

Serving Suggestions

Since these are already individual desserts, you don't really need to do anything to them.

But if you want to dress them up, there are a few possibilities.

Whipped cream: Probably my first choice. The mild creaminess could help soften the aggressive spice profile.
Vanilla ice cream: Another way to bring some cooling, creamy contrast.
A little extra caramel sauce: If you're also wondering where the caramel went, we can solve the problem ourselves.
Chopped pecans: A little crunch could add some welcome texture and works naturally with fall flavors.
Fresh whipped cream and caramel: At this point, we've basically started repairing the dessert, but I'm okay with that.

I'd avoid adding additional cinnamon or pumpkin pie spice.

Trader Joe's has already taken care of that.

Enthusiastically.

An open package of Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan.

FAQs about Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan

The following are commonly asked questions about Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan:

How much is Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan?

It's $3.49 for a package containing two individual flans.

Is Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan seasonal?

Yes. Unlike the regular Caramel Flan, the Pumpkin Flan is a seasonal item.

Is Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan very sweet?

There's certainly sweetness here, but the stronger impression for me was the amount of pumpkin spice rather than sweetness alone.

A Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan on a plate next to the original box.

Final Thoughts

Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan is a seasonal idea that I think sounded better on paper than it tasted in execution.

Pumpkin. Custard. Caramel. Warm spices.

There was plenty of potential here.

Unfortunately, somebody got a little too enthusiastic with the pumpkin spice.

The custard itself is okay, but the spice profile overwhelms the caramel and much of the delicacy I expect from flan. Add a slightly rubbery caramel layer, and the whole thing lands somewhere firmly in the middle.

Not bad. Not great. Just aggressively fall.

At $3.49 for two, trying it isn't a major financial commitment, particularly if you're a serious pumpkin spice fan.

But Trader Joe's gives us an absurd number of pumpkin products every fall.

You can't eat them all. Well, you can try.

But if I'm choosing where to spend my pumpkin-season calories, this one isn't making my starting lineup.

Sometimes pumpkin spice needs to remember it's a supporting character.

Trader Joe's Pumpkin Flan handed it the lead role.

Do you love these reviews?

Don't forget to share your thoughts by going to the "user review" at the bottom of the box (click on the number of stars you believe this product deserves) and leave a comment below.

Are you a fan of SubStack? You can follow me here.